To help parents get the best baby crib mattress for their little ones, this guide goes over the main characteristics of the ten most popular and best-rated crib mattresses. We review their materials, sizes, price range, and main features and go through reviews from verified customers to create a list of pros and cons for each mattress.
10. Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer Dual Sleep Surface Crib Mattress
Just like most products on this list, this baby crib mattress has an extra-firm plant-based foam layer designed for infants and a soft side for toddlers. It’s covered with medical-grade, waterproof stretch knit fabric with extra tight sewn seams that makes it easy to clean.
Customers who purchased this mattress are very happy with it and mention it’s very long-lasting and perfectly fits most cribs on the market today. In addition, parents of toddlers are very happy with the fact that this mattress isn’t bouncy, which means no jumping on the bed!
- Medical grade fabric.
- Easy to clean.
- Knit fabric.
- Contains BPA.
- Has a strong chemical smell for the first few days.
9. Serta Perfect Start Crib and Toddler Mattress
Featuring a firm polyester fiber core, this mattress is very durable and has the perfect firmness for infants’ comfort and safety. At the same time, it’s lightweight enough to be easily flipped over, changed, or cleaned. You will not need to spend too much time cleaning it, however, as it features a vinyl cover that is moisture and stain resistant.
Customers mention this mattress perfectly fits cribs and lasts a long while; however, they highlight the fact that this is not a dual-sided mattress, but a firm one for infants only.
- Moisture and stain resistant.
- Completely silent.
- Not dual-sided; infants only.
8. Newton Wovenaire Crib Mattress
Despite its high level of softness, this breathable and easily-washable mattress is firm and tight enough to prevent suffocation problems. Containing no foam, latex, springs, glue or allergens, it’s perfectly innocuous and safe. As a matter of fact, this product is Greenguard Gold certified, meaning it produces the lowest possible amount of VOCs.
All the magic stands in its two layers of 3D spacers. What’s special about them is the light texture that resembles that of a cloud. Between them, there stands a quality core with a volume made of 10% food-grade polymer while the rest of 90% is simply air.
- Breathable fiber that’s 100% washable.
- Extremely comfortable.
- Some report a strong chemical smell.
7. My First Crib Mattress Memory Foam Crib Mattress
Aiming at providing the highest quality of sleep for your baby, this baby crib mattress is made of premium CertiPUR-US polyurethane foam and has a removable waterproof cover. The hypoallergenic materials offer protection against mites and microbes and contain no lead, phthalates, formaldehyde, ozone depleters, and other toxic additives.
- Completely free of toxic additives.
- Very firm, yet comfortable.
- Too small for some cribs.
6. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Crib & Toddler Mattress
This mattress has a thermo-bonded polyester fiber core which makes it firm and long-lasting. At the same time, its laminated vinyl cover makes it resistant to stains and humidity. Additionally, producing very little chemical emissions, it’s Greenguard Gold certified. All in all, this is a quality choice made in the USA that offers 7 years of warranty.
- Thermo-bonded polyester fiber core.
- Greenguard Gold certified.
- Perfectly fits most cribs.
- Somewhat heavy.
- Some customers report indentation marks after a few weeks of use.
5. Dream On Me Full Size Firm Foam Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
This innovative baby crib mattress proposes a comfortable design with airflow pockets that help keep it fresh without metal vents. Reinforced for additional support and completely waterproof, it’s definitely a durable product that is resistant to external elements. Additionally, it can be easily cleaned using wipes.
On top of that, it earned a Greenguard Gold certification fair and square!
- Airflow pockets for added freshness.
- 10-year warranty.
- Corners are not boxed.
4. Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress
This high-quality mattress has convoluted layers that provide additional softness without sacrificing the necessary firmness for a baby to sleep safely. Largely, this firmness is due to its 120 heavy-duty innerspring coils. It also features an ortho-insulated layer that provides further support. Besides the Greenguard Gold certification, owners will get a lightweight surface with square corners for a perfect fit inside the crib.
Customers who used this mention it’s one of the best baby crib mattress options regarding quality and durability.
- Convoluted layers.
- Ortho-insulated core.
- Exceptional quality.
- Springs can be noisy.
3. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual
Due to its advanced construction, this product is often referred to as the best baby crib mattress for orthopedic means. Hypoallergenic, phthalate free, and Greenguard Gold certified, it’s also safe for the baby’s skin, respiratory system, and immune system. Just like most on this list, this baby crib mattress features a firm side that’s ideal for newborns and a soft, comfy one for toddlers. All in all, this is the third best baby crib mattress currently on the market.
- Greenguard Gold certified.
- Phthalate free.
- Edges are not softened.
2. Milliard Memory Foam Crib Mattress
Without a doubt, this dual sided mattress is the second best baby crib mattress at the moment. The Milliard memory foam crib mattress is Certi-Pur certified due to its resistance to allergens, mold, bacteria, and dust mites. The bamboo layer at the top is completely washable for easy maintenance.
- Comes with a removable bamboo cover.
- Hypoallergenic and Certi-Pur certified.
- Packaging is not vacuum sealed.
1. Moonlight Slumber Organic Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress
This baby crib mattress received both Green Guard Gold and CertiPur certifications. It’s a 2-in-1 system for infants and toddlers. The infant side is made of extra firm foam infused with plant oils, while the toddler side is made of a soft plush that guarantees comfort. In addition, the materials used for this mattress guarantee airflow and its construction prevents liquids from pooling on the mattress.
Be it for infant or toddler use, this is the absolute best baby crib mattress available.
- Inner-woven core.
- Hypoallergenic and organic.
- Squared corners and flat dropped side seams.
- Some customers consider it’s too firm.
Hopefully, this guide provided helpful information that you can use to choose the best baby crib mattress for your infant or toddler. Our personal favorite is the one from Moonlight Slumber, but Milliard and Colgate also made some very reliable options. Do you have a favorite that was not mentioned on this list? Let us know in the comment section!